Skip to content
CoGM
All comparisons

CoGM and Guild Manager for WoW Forever guilds

Both run WoW Forever guilds. Here is what each one offers, row by row: our side from our own pages, Guild Manager's from its public pages. CoGM has an in-game addon in beta testing, soft reserves, loot council as a raid loot rule, and professions, and each feature we offer links the page that shows it.

Set up your Forever guild

Free up to 30 members with uploads per guild. Pro $10/mo for up to 300 members with uploads, plus $5/mo per 200 more.

CoGM's side of the 16 rows

10 of 16rows marked yes
5rows in part
15rows that link the page showing them

16 features compared: CoGM against Guild Manager.

YesIn partNo
FeatureCoGMWoW Forever guild tools, live nowGuild ManagerGuild platform for several games
Free planIn partUp to 30 members with uploads per guild; signing in never counts.See itYesOne guild, with no member cap. Its pricing page lists recruitment and loot tools only under Core.
Paid planYesPro is $10/mo per guild, up to 300 members with uploads per guild, then +200 for $5/month.See itYesCore is $19.99 a month ($14.99 a month paid yearly), covers up to 4 guilds, and adds the recruitment and loot tools.
WoW Forever statusYesLive now.See itYesListed as live.
In-game addonIn partIn beta testing, not released yet. Shows soft reserves and wishlists on item tooltips, and a loot window with each drop's reserves, DKP and rolls.See itYesSyncs characters and the guild roster, records raids, and shows soft and hard reserves on item tooltips.
Soft reservesYesOn Pro. Officers set one to four picks per raid, and picks close when the raid starts.See itYesRaiders reserve before the raid, the list locks at the pull, and it exports to Gargul.
Gargul import and exportYesOn Pro. Paste Gargul's award history to mark wishlist items won, with no DKP charged, and copy the raid's soft reserves and the wishlist order out in Gargul's format.See itYesImports and exports soft reserves with Gargul.
Hard reservesNoNot offered on CoGM.YesShown next to soft reserves on item tooltips.
Loot councilIn partFree. Set it as the raid's loot rule and it shows on the raid.See itYesOn Core. Council votes, a side-by-side view of candidates, and a reason on every award.
DKPYesOn Pro. Attendance and voice rewards, decay by hand or on a schedule, and a full ledger.See itYesOn Core. Attendance rewards, scheduled decay and a full ledger.
Loot auctions in DiscordYesOn Pro. Open or sealed bids, Main spec and Off spec tiers, anti-snipe, and 90-second lots while the raid waits.See itYesOn Core. Officers start, award, reverse, relist and close auctions from Discord.
Raid signupsYesFree. Tank, Healer and DPS seats on one Discord post, with templates for Barrow Deeps, Hyjal Summit and Onyxia's Lair.See itYesBarrow Deeps and Hyjal Summit come set up with role targets, waitlists and templates.
Voice attendanceYesFree. From the raid's voice channel, from the signups, or marked by hand.See itYesFree. Voice snapshots per activity, by hand or on a schedule.
Raid log from the gameIn partIn the beta addon. It logs raid joins and leaves, awards and rolls, and officers paste the export on the Loot page.See itYesThe addon logs members, boss pulls and kills, drops and rolls, and Guild Manager merges several officers' logs into one report.
Roster from the gameIn partEach member's characters fill in from Battle.net. The guild's in-game roster comes through the beta addon: officers export it with /cogm roster.See itYesOfficers publish the in-game guild roster, and levels and classes update from it.
ProfessionsYesFree. Each raider's professions and up to 8 pinned recipes.See itYesA profession registry, a recipe directory and crafting requests.
Guild bankYesOn Pro. Gold, item stock by category, member requests and /bank search in Discord.See itYesOn Core. Deposits, requests and a currency treasury with its history.
  • CoGM WoW Forever guild tools, live now
  • Guild Manager Guild platform for several games
  1. Free plan

    CoGMIn partUp to 30 members with uploads per guild; signing in never counts.See it
    Guild ManagerYesOne guild, with no member cap. Its pricing page lists recruitment and loot tools only under Core.
  2. Paid plan

    CoGMYesPro is $10/mo per guild, up to 300 members with uploads per guild, then +200 for $5/month.See it
    Guild ManagerYesCore is $19.99 a month ($14.99 a month paid yearly), covers up to 4 guilds, and adds the recruitment and loot tools.
  3. WoW Forever status

    CoGMYesLive now.See it
    Guild ManagerYesListed as live.
  4. In-game addon

    CoGMIn partIn beta testing, not released yet. Shows soft reserves and wishlists on item tooltips, and a loot window with each drop's reserves, DKP and rolls.See it
    Guild ManagerYesSyncs characters and the guild roster, records raids, and shows soft and hard reserves on item tooltips.
  5. Soft reserves

    CoGMYesOn Pro. Officers set one to four picks per raid, and picks close when the raid starts.See it
    Guild ManagerYesRaiders reserve before the raid, the list locks at the pull, and it exports to Gargul.
  6. Gargul import and export

    CoGMYesOn Pro. Paste Gargul's award history to mark wishlist items won, with no DKP charged, and copy the raid's soft reserves and the wishlist order out in Gargul's format.See it
    Guild ManagerYesImports and exports soft reserves with Gargul.
  7. Hard reserves

    CoGMNoNot offered on CoGM.
    Guild ManagerYesShown next to soft reserves on item tooltips.
  8. Loot council

    CoGMIn partFree. Set it as the raid's loot rule and it shows on the raid.See it
    Guild ManagerYesOn Core. Council votes, a side-by-side view of candidates, and a reason on every award.
  9. DKP

    CoGMYesOn Pro. Attendance and voice rewards, decay by hand or on a schedule, and a full ledger.See it
    Guild ManagerYesOn Core. Attendance rewards, scheduled decay and a full ledger.
  10. Loot auctions in Discord

    CoGMYesOn Pro. Open or sealed bids, Main spec and Off spec tiers, anti-snipe, and 90-second lots while the raid waits.See it
    Guild ManagerYesOn Core. Officers start, award, reverse, relist and close auctions from Discord.
  11. Raid signups

    CoGMYesFree. Tank, Healer and DPS seats on one Discord post, with templates for Barrow Deeps, Hyjal Summit and Onyxia's Lair.See it
    Guild ManagerYesBarrow Deeps and Hyjal Summit come set up with role targets, waitlists and templates.
  12. Voice attendance

    CoGMYesFree. From the raid's voice channel, from the signups, or marked by hand.See it
    Guild ManagerYesFree. Voice snapshots per activity, by hand or on a schedule.
  13. Raid log from the game

    CoGMIn partIn the beta addon. It logs raid joins and leaves, awards and rolls, and officers paste the export on the Loot page.See it
    Guild ManagerYesThe addon logs members, boss pulls and kills, drops and rolls, and Guild Manager merges several officers' logs into one report.
  14. Roster from the game

    CoGMIn partEach member's characters fill in from Battle.net. The guild's in-game roster comes through the beta addon: officers export it with /cogm roster.See it
    Guild ManagerYesOfficers publish the in-game guild roster, and levels and classes update from it.
  15. Professions

    CoGMYesFree. Each raider's professions and up to 8 pinned recipes.See it
    Guild ManagerYesA profession registry, a recipe directory and crafting requests.
  16. Guild bank

    CoGMYesOn Pro. Gold, item stock by category, member requests and /bank search in Discord.See it
    Guild ManagerYesOn Core. Deposits, requests and a currency treasury with its history.

Sources

Our rows come from our own pages, and each feature we offer links its page. Guild Manager's rows come from its public WoW Forever, addon, comparison and pricing pages, read on October 13 and 14, 2026. Tell us in our Discord if a row is out of date.

More for Forever guilds on CoGM

Weekly availability and split nights

Raiders mark the nights they can make, and one raid night can split in two. Both are free.

cogm.app Β· Ashen Vow Β· Overview
A WoW Forever guild overview on cogm.app with the week's raid nights
Sample guild. The week at the top shows each raid night.

Characters from Battle.net

Members link Battle.net and pick their characters from a list. Level, class, spec and gear refresh once a day while they play. Under level 10, /upload reads the character panel, and gear can also come from a SimulationCraft paste.

cogm.app Β· Claim characters

From Battle.net

Brannoc#1873 Β· last read 2 min ago

  • Picked: Aldric StormvaneLv 41 Warrior
  • Picked: Maelis DawnhollowLv 33 Priest
  • Kessa ThornwildLv 38 Hunter Β· On your roster
  • Tovin AshbrightLv 17 Mage
Claim 2 characters

Under level 10? Run /upload with your character panel.

Group finder in Discord

On every plan, /lfg posts dungeons, battlegrounds and raids with the faction and the open seats.

Discord Β· #looking-for-group
A WoW Forever group post in Discord with its members and open seats

Party builder and auto-fill

On Pro, officers seat raiders into groups and post the layout to Discord. Auto-fill seats every attending raider who has no group yet, spreading each role evenly.

Wishlists with a priority

On Pro, raiders list the items they want, each with a priority, and the beta addon shows them on item tooltips.

WoW Forever Β· CoGM addonBeta

Manaflare Robes

Item Level 65

Binds when picked up

ChestCloth

100 Armor

Classes: Mage

Requires Level 60

Manaflare Regalia (0/6)

Manaflare Crown

Manaflare Robes

(2) Set : Improves your chance to hit by 1.0%.

(3) Set : Reduces the cooldown on your Counterspell spell by 5 sec.

CoGM

Soft reserved (2): Emberlyn, Tamsin

Wishlist 1Β Β FendrelΒ Β 60 DKP

Loot

Click a name to award. Bank is BoE. DE logs a disenchant. Roll starts a roll-off.

Manaflare Robes

Spidersilk Boots

SR / wishlist

  • SREmberlyn145 DKPNeed
  • SRTamsin90 DKPNeed

AwardΒ Β (in this raid)

EmberlynTamsinKaldrinElandraBrannvarWickspark
DKP35BankDESkipRoll
Sample raid. The addon is in beta testing: the tooltip shows the item's soft reserves and wishlist, the loot window shows each drop's reserves, DKP and rolls.

Ready to switch?

Free up to 30 members with uploads per guild. Pro $10/mo for up to 300 members with uploads, plus $5/mo per 200 more.